Tier 3 Writing Intervention: How SRSD Makes It Doable

Implementing Effective Writing Solutions for Students in Need

Within a Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS), Tier 3 is the most intensive level of intervention. Only a small percentage of students receive this individualized, high-frequency support, but for them, it is often the difference between continued struggle and measurable progress.

When we think about Tier 3 writing intervention, we usually work with students who experience persistent challenges in areas such as planning, organizing ideas, generating sentences, maintaining attention, or managing the anxiety that accompanies writing. For many, writing difficulties are compounded by decoding, fluency, comprehension, or other reading difficulties.

It’s important to stress that Tier 3 isn’t a separate universe. It follows the same logic as Tiers 1 and 2. The difference is intensity: instruction is more explicit, more precise, more frequent, and driven by close progress monitoring. Decisions are based on data, and instruction is continually adjusted. (MTSS4Success)

When Tier 3 succeeds, schools stop guessing and commit to evidence-based instruction. That means identifying a small set of high-leverage skills, choosing evidence-based strategies, setting clear goals, teaching explicitly, and checking progress frequently enough to make real-time adjustments. That description aligns directly with Self-Regulated Strategy Development (SRSD), a framework built for students who need individualized instruction, and it has decades of evidence to prove it works.

A Quick History: SRSD before “Tier 3” Existed

The language of MTSS and “Tier 3” is relatively new, but SRSD has predated it for decades. In the early 1980s, Dr. Karen R. Harris and Dr. Steve Graham began working with students with significant writing difficulties and learning disabilities. They observed that traditional instruction wasn’t sufficient. Students needed explicit instruction in writing strategies and the self-regulation processes that drive learning: setting goals, engaging in positive self-talk, monitoring progress, and reflecting on success.

This blend of explicit strategy instruction and self-regulation became SRSD. Over the next 40 years, study after study confirmed its effectiveness not only for students with disabilities but also for struggling writers, typical learners, and advanced writers. (Institute of Education Sciences)

Today, SRSD is widely recognized by the research community and independent reviewers as an evidence-based practice in writing instruction. While refinements continue, the foundation remains the same: teach strategies explicitly, promote self-regulation, and gradually release responsibility to the student. (SAGE Journals)

What Tier 3 Writing Intervention Looks Like

In most schools, Tier 3 writing support has four defining features:

• Intensity and Time: Daily or near-daily sessions, often 40–60 minutes, delivered in addition to core instruction.
• Individualization: Each plan targets a particular set of skills, such as writing a clear topic sentence, generating reasons, or using transitions effectively. Instruction adapts as progress monitoring data comes in.
• Frequent Progress Monitoring: Weekly (or more frequent) checks inform decisions about when to increase support, adjust goals, or fade scaffolds.
• Instructional Match: Students work on grade-level-aligned tasks broken into manageable steps, supported by explicit modeling, guided practice, feedback, and repeated opportunities for success.

SRSD aligns perfectly with this model. It provides named, research-tested strategies like TREE for opinion writing and TIDE for informative writing. It offers a predictable lesson routine that blends explicit teaching with self-regulation practices. Most importantly, it builds the internal goal setting, monitoring, and reflection habits that struggling writers need to become independent.

Why SRSD Is So Effective for Tier 3

1. It addresses the real bottlenecks.
Tier 3 writers struggle most with planning, organization, and sustaining effort. SRSD tackles these directly: students learn to generate ideas before drafting, structure writing around clear patterns (e.g., topic–reasons–ending), and use self-regulation tools like goal setting and checklists to stay on track.

2. It has a proven track record with struggling writers.
Multiple studies, including research with students with learning disabilities, show significant gains in writing quality, length, and organization after SRSD instruction. Students taught with SRSD consistently outperform peers receiving traditional instruction, and many show increased motivation to write.

3. It works across tiers.
The same strategies used in Tier 1 and Tier 2 classrooms can be intensified for Tier 3 by slowing the pace, modeling more often, and keeping supports in place longer. This consistency reduces stigma and makes it easier for students to transfer what they learn in the intervention back into the general classroom.

4. It builds independence rather than dependence.
Tier 3 is not meant to be a permanent placement. SRSD helps students internalize the moves of good writers: setting goals, talking themselves through challenges, checking their work against a strategy, and celebrating success. As students master these habits, they can confidently return to less intensive supports.

SRSD’s Six Stages, Adapted for Tier 3

SRSD is taught through six flexible stages. In Tier 3, each stage tightens to provide more repetition, structure, and feedback.

1. Develop Background Knowledge
Identify the specific barriers to effective writing, such as difficulty generating ideas, organizing reasons, or adding evidence. Start with a brief warm-up that primes students to think about reasons, examples, and transitions.

2. Discuss It
Make the strategy’s purpose clear: “This helps me plan so I don’t stare at a blank page.” Turn broad goals into concrete targets (e.g., “two clear reasons with one example each”). Tie goals to the student’s values, like finishing on time or feeling proud to share work.

3. Model It (Think-Aloud)
Provide frequent, short models instead of one long demonstration. Narrate self-talk (“If I get stuck, I check my TREE strategy”). Model overcoming mistakes or writer’s block, not just the polished version.

4. Memorize It
In Tier 3, mnemonics must become automatic. Over-teach TREE, TIDE, or POW+TREE using call-and-response, quick checks, and personal cue cards. Students should be able to recite and explain the strategy steps before applying them in writing.

5. Support It (Guided Practice)
This stage requires the most time. Begin with structured prompts and graphic organizers, then gradually fade to mnemonic cards and memory. Provide immediate, specific feedback tied to strategy steps.

6. Independent Performance
Supports remain nearby but discreet, such as a strategy card taped inside a notebook. Weekly progress monitoring and student self-checks continue. Supports are faded only when data show consistent success.

Sample Tier 3 SRSD Plan

Student Profile

A sixth-grade student with a history of learning disabilities in writing produces short, unorganized responses and often avoids writing. Goals for the next 6–8 weeks are:

• Use TREE to plan and draft a paragraph with one opinion, two reasons, and a wrap-up.
• Change the goal the student sets after accomplishing the first one.
• Complete a self-monitoring checklist in under 2 minutes after each write.

Schedule

Tier 3 requires frequent, intensive practice to build fluency and confidence. Sessions occur:

• Frequency: 5 times per week
• Duration: 45 minutes each
• Format: 1:1 or 1:2 instruction to allow individualized attention

Session Routine

• 5-minute Strategy Warm-Up: Oral rehearsal of TREE and one quick review question anchors the student in the strategy and creates predictability.
• 5–8 minute Model & Discussion: The teacher models one step of TREE with a think-aloud, explaining why it helps. Short, frequent models reinforce learning.
• 20–25 minute Guided or Independent Writing: Students begin with scaffolds like graphic organizers and gradually rely only on mnemonic cards. Teacher feedback is immediate and specific.
• 5 minutes Self-Monitoring & Goal Reflection: Student completes a self-checklist, reflects on progress, and may briefly conference with the teacher.
• 2–5 minutes Progress Tracking: Teacher logs checklist completion and rubric data.

Progress Monitoring

Weekly short writes are scored with a focused rubric (organization + reasons + wrap-up) and word count. The aim is steady growth, not perfection. Scaffolds are adjusted based on data to ensure responsiveness.

What the Research Says

• Strong effects for struggling writers and students with disabilities. SRSD instruction leads to improved writing quality, length, and organization, with gains surpassing those of typical instruction. (SAGE Journals)
• Meta-analytic support. Reviews across decades show SRSD produces large, statistically significant effects for students with and without disabilities. (acuresearchbank)
• Independent recognition. The What Works Clearinghouse has published an intervention report on SRSD, validating its evidence base for leaders. (Institute of Education Sciences)

How Tier 3 Connects to Tiers 1 and 2

When schools use SRSD in Tier 1, Tier 3 becomes far more efficient. Students already recognize the mnemonics, have seen think-alouds, and understand the language of self-regulation. Tier 3 can then zero in on filling deep gaps like generating reasons or adding evidence rather than reteaching the whole framework. This shared foundation is a key reason SRSD scales seamlessly across all tiers of instruction.

---

Practical Tips for Tier 3 with SRSD

1. Tighten your aim. Select one or two must-address skills for 4–8 weeks (e.g., plan with TREE; add examples to reasons). Small wins build motivation.
2. Over-teach self-regulation. Have students verbalize strategies, set micro-goals, and complete self-checks. Seeing themselves succeed fuels persistence.
3. Write short, write often. Multiple brief writings yield more data, feedback cycles, and less avoidance than one long assignment.
4. Keep data simple. Track words written, rubric scores, and independence. Share graphs with students weekly to highlight progress.
5. Connect to content areas. Use science and social studies prompts so students experience transfer to the curriculum.
6. Involve families. Provide simple at-home routines such as “Ask me to say my TREE steps,” or “Listen as I explain my two reasons.”

When Progress Stalls

Even with strong instruction, plateaus happen. Here are quick adjustments:

• Zoom in further: Break goals into smaller targets (e.g., one detail per reason).
• Re-model the shaky step: Pinpoint the problem area and model it again the next day.
• Shift the entry point: Try oral rehearsal or sentence starters before drafting.
• Reset goals: Set an easier target to rebuild confidence and momentum.

What Leaders Should Know

For administrators and coaches, Tier 3 success depends on systems:

• Materials: Cue cards, graphic organizers, self-monitoring sheets.
• Time: Protected daily Tier 3 slots, even in tight schedules.
• Data cadence: Decide what to track weekly and review regularly.
• PD & coaching: Give teachers time to practice think-alouds and analyze Tier 3 data in coaching cycles.
• Continuity: Encourage Tier 1 teachers to use the same mnemonics and language so students move across tiers smoothly.

Credible Places to Learn More

• National Center on Intensive Intervention – Tools and guides linking intensive intervention with MTSS, including progress monitoring.  (Intensive Intervention)
• Center on MTSS – Clear explanations and visuals on Tier 3 for staff development. (MTSS4Success)
• What Works Clearinghouse SRSD Report – Independent review of SRSD’s origins and effects. Institute of Education Sciences
• Research on SRSD with struggling writers and students with learning disabilities – Harris, Graham & Mason (2006); Saddler (2006/2007); Graham (2005); and meta-analytic reviews. (ResearchGate)

The Takeaway for Teachers

Tier 3 writing intervention is not mysterious—it’s focused, frequent, and responsive. For students with persistent reading difficulties, challenges with fluency or comprehension, or learning disabilities, success hinges on explicit instruction, individualized goals, and progress monitoring.

SRSD provides a clear structure: teach a strategy explicitly, build self-regulation, and collect data to guide next steps. Because SRSD operates seamlessly across tiers, students don’t feel like they’re in a different system when receiving Tier 3 support. Instead, they experience consistency, clarity, and, most importantly, academic success.

If your school already implements SRSD in Tiers 1 and 2, adding a targeted Tier 3 cycle is the natural next step. It completes the picture: a coherent, tiered intervention system where every student, including those who struggle the most, has a way forward grounded in evidence, individualized instruction, and daily wins.

---